buy now

Comparative Vampire Mythology
Part One
by S. A. Rudy

 

A comparison of various popular sources for vampire lore against the myths of history. Do all vampire have fangs? Can all vampires reproduce? How do the popular vampires of the 20th century live and die and hunt and feed? S. A. Rudy takes a look at five modern vampire themes.

This is a list I've compiled of common vampire myths and how they appear in contemporary fiction. I'm only using five vfictional universes here because any more columns would be much too wide to be readable.

If a myth appears here, it means that somewhere, in some legend, movie, piece of fiction, etc. I've seen it (no matter how obscure), even if it doesn't apply to any of my examples. A question mark ( ?) in place of an entry means that I don't know how or whether the myth applies. An entry with a question mark ( ?) next to the entry means that I gave it my best guess and an entry with an asterisk ( *) indicates that the answer is too complex to put in that tiny little box and I used my best approximation. The list is grouped into subtopics, but is otherwise in no particular order. If anyone is interested in see an annotation of this list for the marked entries, let me know.

If you'd like to be helpful, please do email me with additions or corrections and I'll put them in. (Please mention vampires or myths in the subject header so I'll be sure to notice it.) I especially like to hear about myths I haven't included or answers to the question marked entries. Go ahead, argue with me, I'm nothing like infallible. If you'd like to see more, encourage me!

My examples are as follows:

· WoD: The "World of Darkness" from the Storyteller(tm) line of products published by White Wolf

· BtVS: Buffy the Vampire Slayer, a television show currently on the WB network Tuesdays at 8pm.

· FK: Forever Knight, a syndicated television show being shown in reruns by the Sci-Fi Channel.

· AB: Anita Blake, a series of novels by Laurell K. Hamilton

· AR: Anne Rice's Vampire Chronicles .

 

Comparative Vampire Mythology
Part Two
by S. A. Rudy

 

Myth

WoD

BtVS

FK

AB

AR

General

Vampires are inherently evil

Mostly

Yes

No

Maybe

No

Vampires are a kind of undead

Yes

Yes

Maybe

Yes

Yes

Vampires are "normal" humans, just altered

No

No

Maybe

No

No

Vampires are a different species (subspecies) than humans

Yes

Yes

Maybe

Yes

No

Vampirism can be cured

Rarely

Not Really

Rarely

No

No

Identifying features

Vampire skin is unnaturally pale and cold to the touch

Usually

No ?

Yes

Yes

Yes

The pallor and coldness decreases after feeding

Yes

no info

no info

Yes

Yes

Vampires are hideously deformed

Some

No

No

* No

No

Vampires have long and pointed fingernails

No

No

No

No

Yes

Vampires change appearance when angered, stressed, using vampiric abilities, etc. (e.g. glowing eyes or deformed features)

No

Yes

Yes

No

No

Vampires don't need to breathe

Yes

Yes

?

Yes

Yes

Vampires, in fact, don't breathe, unless they consciously intend to

Yes

Yes ?

No ?

some
times

No

You become a vampire by ...

... being killed by one (with no further action necessary)

No

No

No ?

No

No

... drinking (or being injected by) a vampire's blood (without dying first)

No

No

No

No

* sort
of

... suffering fatal blood loss and drinking (or being injected by) a vampire's blood

Yes

Yes

Yes

No

Yes

... dying after being bitten by or drinking from a vampire

No

No

No

No

No

... dying after repeatedly being bitten by or drinking from a vampire

No

No

No

Yes

No

... participating in some sort of ritual

No

No

No

No

No

... being willing (i.e. an unwilling subject can't be brought over)

No

No

?

No

No

... committing suicide, dying unbaptized/apostate, not being buried in consecrated ground, etc

No

No

No

No

No

... being the victim of an explicit curse

No

No

No

No

No

The new vampire appears dead for some time (often 3 days) before rising

No

Yes

No ?

Yes

No

A newly made vampire will wake ravenous and will tend to attack anything within range

* No

Yes ?

Yes

Yes

Yes

... being born that way

No

No

No

No

No

... getting infected by some kind of "virus"

No

No

Yes

No

No

Killing/Hurting Vampires

A stake through the heart causes permanent death

No

Yes

* Yes

Usually

* some
times

A stake through the heart causes paralysis only

Yes

No

No

No

No

Sunlight causes instant combustion and is nearly always fatal

n/a

Yes

n/a

Yes

* some
times

Sunlight causes severe burns and discomfort and is fatal after extended exposure

Yes

n/a

Yes

n/a

* some
times

Sunlight inflicts no or mild (sunburn) damage

n/a

n/a

n/a

Rarely

No

Sunlight must be direct to be effective

usually

Yes

Yes

Yes ?

?

Any UV source (e.g. tanning lamps) will function the same as real sunlight

?

no info

Yes

No ?

No

Sunblock provides some protection from sunlight

No

No

No

No

Yes

Sunblock provides total protection from sunlight

No

No

No

No

No

Vampires suffer more than usual damage from fire

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

No

Vampires suffer more than usual damage from silver

No

No

No

Yes

No

Vampires suffer more than usual damage from wood

No

No

** Yes

No

No

Beheading causes permanent death

Yes

Yes

* Usually

Yes

Yes

It takes special effort to make a vampire stay dead (e.g. cutting off the head, sewing the mouth shut around a clove of garlic and burying the body at a crossroads)

No

No

* No

No

No

Dead vampires disperse to dust regardless of age

No

Yes

No

No

No

Dead vampires decompose/disintegrate as a function of age

Yes

n/a

n/a

Yes

No

Animals

Vampires can be sustained by animal blood

* Usually

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Vampires can be sustained indefinitely by animal blood (without suffering deleterious side effects)

* Usually

* Yes

Yes

No

Yes

Animals can become vampires

?

?

Yes

No ?

?

Vampires have control over animals

Some

Some

None

Some

Some

Vampires have control only over specific animals

n/a

n/a

n/a

Yes

?

Vampires can summon certain animals

Some

no info

None

Some

No

Animals can sense vampires and feel threatened by them

Some

no info

some
times ?

Yes

Yes

When you are bitten by a vampire (and live) ...

... they gain some power over you

No

No

?

Yes

No

... you acquire some vampiric traits

No

No

Yes

* some
times

No

When you drink from a vampire (without being dead first) ...

... they gain some power over you

Yes

no info

?

* Yes

Yes

... you acquire some vampiric traits

Yes

no info

?

* some
times

No

Fangs

Vampires have fangs

Some

All

All

All

All ?

Fangs are retractable

Yes

Yes

Yes

No

Yes

Fangs are hollow (like a snake, but for sucking, not injecting)

No

No

Yes

No

No

Invitations

Vampires require an invitation to enter a private dwelling

No

Yes

No

Yes

No

That invitation can be retracted

n/a

Yes

No

Yes

n/a

Crosses ...

... always repel vampires

No

Yes

* Usually

No

No

... require the belief of the wielder to repel vampires

* some
times

No

No

No

No

... require the belief of the vampire to repel vampires

* some
times

No

* Yes

No

No

... if effective, burns vampiric flesh on contact

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

n/a

... if effective, burns everything on contact

No

Yes

No

No

n/a

... may be replaced with other religious symbols according to the belief system of the wielder and/or vampire

Yes

no info

Yes

Yes

n/a

... are ineffective

No

No

No

No

Yes

Holy Water

... is ineffective

* Usually

No

No ?

No

Yes

... if effective, burns (like acid) and can cause severe damage in quantity

Yes

Yes

Yes ?

Yes

n/a

... can reverse or halt effects of vampiric attack

No

n/a

Yes

Yes

n/a

Eucharistic wafers can be substituted for/function similarly to holy water

No

no info

?

Yes

n/a

Mirrors

Vampires do not reflect in mirrors or water

* Rarely

* Yes

No

No

No

Vampires do not appear in photographs or on film

* Rarely

No

No

No

No

Vampires are repulsed by mirrors

No

No

No

No

No

Daytime

Vampires cannot function at all during the day

No

No

No

Yes

No

If awake at all, vampires are sluggish during the day

Yes

No

No

some
times

No

Only the oldest/most powerful vampires can function during the day

* n/a

No

n/a

Yes

No

Vampires can function normally during the day, provided they avoid the sun

No

Yes

Yes

No

Yes

Vampires can function normally during the day (without exception)

No

No

No

No

No

Vampires can function normally during the day, but without their vampiric abilities

No

No

No

No

No

Supernatural Abilities

Damage resistance, superhuman strength and fast healing

All

All

All

All

Yes

Superhuman perception (e.g. sight, hearing, mystical)

Some

no info

All ?

Most

Yes

Hypnotic mind control

Some

* Some

* All

All

Some

Shapeshifting (often a wolf or bat)

Some

Not really

None

very
rare

No

Superhuman speed

Some

debatable

All

Most

Yes

Flight/Levitation

Rarely

No

Yes

Some

Yes

Inhuman stealth (Sometimes to the point of invisibility)

some
times

debatable

Yes ?

* Yes

Yes

Control over weather

Rarely

None

None

Some

No

Mist form

Some

no info

None

Some ?

No

Miscellaneous Supernatural Restrictions

Vampires are repelled by garlic

Rarely

* Yes

Yes

No ?

No

Vampires no longer need to eat or drink regular food

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Vampires can no longer eat solid food

Usually

No ?

Yes

Yes

Yes

Vampires can no longer eat or drink at all (other than blood)

Usually

No

* No

Yes

Yes

Vampires can eat or drink, but get nothing out of it

No

No

No

No

n/a

Vampires can become intoxicated by directly ingesting drugs or alcohol

No ?

Yes

No ?

No

n/a

Vampires can become intoxicated by drugs or alcohol secondhand (e.g. by drinking from an intoxicated victim)

Yes ?

Yes

No ?

Yes

Yes

Vampires must sleep with a sample of their home soil

Rarely

no info

No

No

No

Vampires cannot cross running water

Rarely

No

No

No

No

Vampires cannot cross a line of salt

No

No

No

No

No

Vampires are compelled to stop and count numerous objects (often grain) thrown into their path

No

No

No

No

No

Hierarchy

Vampires are societally compelled to obey their sire/creator

Yes

Maybe

Yes

Yes

Yes

Vampires are mystically compelled to obey their sire/creator

No

No

Maybe

Yes ?

No

Beyond the "generic", Vampires tend to have the same supernatural traits/abilities as their sire/creator

Yes

no info

no info

Yes

Some

Relationship with Other Supernaturals (especially Shapeshifters)

Vampires and Werewolves (shapeshifters) are natural allies

No

No

n/a

sort
of

n/a

Vampires and Werewolves (shapeshifters) are natural enemies

Yes

no info

n/a

No

n/a

Vampires and Werewolves (shapeshifters) could care less about each other

No

no info

n/a

No

n/a

Werewolf (shapeshifter) blood is extra yummy

some
times

no info

n/a

No

n/a

Werewolf (shapeshifter) blood is indigestible

No

no info

n/a

No

n/a

Vampires can be infected with lycanthropy (become werewolves, etc.)

No

no info

n/a

No

n/a

Werewolves (shapeshifters) can become vampires

* Yes

no info

n/a

?

n/a

Werewolves (shapeshifters) can become vampires (but lose all of their were abilities)

No

no info

n/a

?

n/a

Miscellaneous

Vampires feed on something other than blood (life essence, emotions, etc)

No

No

No

No

No

Vampires' hearts no longer beat

Most

no info

* Yes

?

No

A vampire's heart only beats if the vampire wills it to

maybe

no info

No ?

?

n/a

Vampires can bear children

No

No

No

No

No

Vampires can father children

No

No

No

No

No

A child of a vampire and a mortal results in a "Dhampir", with some vampiric abilities and fewer of the weaknesses

n/a

n/a

n/a

n/a

n/a

 

 




 
  landscape seal